I recently finished two more books, The Magician’s nephew and The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe. Or, as I like to call them, Genesis and the Gospel according to C.S. Lewis. Reading them while reading the bible was pretty interesting. I knew they had religious undertones, but I didn’t realize that they were in parts simple retellings of bible stories. I assume that everyone else has read these books at one point or another, so I won’t bother with a review or anything, I’ll just give some impressions. I have never actually read the books before, so I had a number of expectations that were blown away.
First, I didn’t realize that the Magician’s Nephew was written long after The Lion The Witch and The Wardrobe. Reading them in chronological order rather than publication order was rather revealing. For example, I am used to science fiction and fantasy being more about story and details, than about mood. These stories were clearly placed to set mood and get feeling across. Once those had been taken care of, telling certain bible stories was next. Cohesion in plot and character motivation took a back seat. The professor in the Lion the witch and the wardrobe was a very different person from the nephew in the earlier book. In addition to the professor’s changing personality there seemed to be a number of plot holes that you could drive a truck through.
It was also interesting that he spent a couple days in Narnia while the kids were there for a lifetime. That really shocked me. I’m not sure what I was expecting, but I guess I thought that the rest of the books would be repeated trips while they were the rulers of Narnia. Now I am really curious to see what happens in the other books. (After I read Harry Potter I guess.)
The final big thing is that I am now used to modern KidLit. Between Harry Potter and Ember, I expect a certain level of writing in my KidLit books. The Narnia books seem to either be written for a younger audience, or just aren’t written as well.
Having said all that, I really did enjoy the books. In particular I found the creation myth to be a really interesting spin on Genesis. Putting elements of Jesus in to the Creator was a really neat way to give a level of compassion to the creation story. And I will certainly read the rest because I am interested to see what else they do, and if they actually do pull together all the plot holes. Clearly some of the stuff in the last book (the first one chronologically) was setting up things that happened later. It will be interesting to see how that pans out. And also, if Aslan created the universe, who’s rules does he bow to? Who is this emperor across the sea? I will be excited to read more and find out. Especially since the books don’t take that long to read.